LOYALTY
Points vs Stamp Cards: Which Loyalty Program Fits Your Shop?
By Replily.ai team · · 6 min read
Stamp cards reward how often someone visits. Points reward how much they spend. If most of your customers buy roughly the same thing each time, such as a coffee, stamps are easy to understand. If basket sizes vary a lot, as in a minimart or salon, points are fairer because a big spender earns more than someone buying one item.
How a stamp card works
The customer gets one stamp per visit or per qualifying item. After a fixed number of stamps, often eight to ten, they get a reward. It is simple, staff explain it in one line, and customers see progress at a glance.
The weakness is that every visit counts the same. A customer spending five dollars and one spending fifty earn the same stamp. Paper cards also get lost, forgotten at home, or stamped more than once by a friendly staff member.
How a points program works
The customer earns points in proportion to spend, for example one point per dollar. Points are swapped for rewards from a catalogue: a free drink, a discount, a product. Because earning follows spend, your best customers naturally earn faster, and you can add higher-value rewards for them.
Points need a system to track them, which is why they are usually digital. That also means you can see who your regulars are and how often they come back.
Which one suits your shop
- Coffee bar or bubble tea stall with similar order sizes: stamps or points both work. Points with a low first reward feel almost like stamps.
- Minimart or convenience store: points. Basket sizes vary too much for stamps to be fair.
- Salon or barber: points, often combined with VIP tiers, because a colour treatment and a fringe trim are very different spends.
- Bakery: either. Points let you reward a whole-cake order properly.
A middle path: points that feel like stamps
You can make a points program as simple as a stamp card. Set one point per dollar, make the first reward reachable in about the same number of visits as a stamp card, and show the balance on the customer's phone. Customers get the clarity of stamps and you get fairness and data.
In Replily.ai the customer's wallet shows their points and how far they are from the next tier, and the cashier sees the same balance when scanning their card.
Switching from paper stamps without upsetting regulars
- Honour existing cards for a set period, for example until the end of next month, and add points equal to their stamps when they join the digital program.
- Tell regulars in person. A short line at the counter works better than a poster.
- Keep the first digital reward the same as the old stamp reward, so nobody feels they lost out.
- Stop issuing new paper cards on a clear date.
The bottom line
Choose stamps if your orders are uniform and you want the simplest possible start. Choose points if basket sizes vary or you want to reward your biggest customers more. A digital points program with a low first reward gives you most of the benefits of both.
Replily.ai runs points, rewards and automatic VIP tiers from the same POS you take sales on. Start free on one device.
Run your counter and your loyalty program in one place
Cash and PayNow checkout, digital receipts, points and VIP tiers on the Android tablet you already own. Free on one device, no card needed.
Start free on one device